Our "Forward" Pack
Here are the packs averages after 3 games this season:
Blair: 188 minutes (1 carry per 5.52 minutes) 34 Hit-ups for 234m (6.8m per carry) 64 tackles 6 Missed
Norrie: 128 minutes (1 carry per 4 minutes) 32 Hit-ups for 249m (7.7m per carry) 67 tackles 1 Missed
Lowe: 81 minutes (1 carry per 3.6 minutes) 22 Hit-ups for 173m (7.8m per carry) 54 tackles 5 Missed
Manu: 181 minutes (1 carry per 6.03 minutes) 30 Hit-ups for 243m (8.1m per carry) 57 tackles 4 Missed
Proctor: 184 minutes (1 carry per 7.07 minutes) 26 Hit-ups for 199m (7.6m per carry) 71 tackles 3 Missed
Lowrie: 150 minutes (1 carry per 7.1 minutes) 21 Hit-ups for 130m (6.1m per carry) 65 tackles 6 Missed
Thompsom: 79 minutes (1 carry per 4.1 minutes) 19 Hit-ups for 137m (7.2m per carry) 48 tackles 3 Missed
Bromwich: 104 minutes (1 carry per 3.25 minutes) 32 Hit-ups for 247m (7.7m per carry) 63 tackles 7 Missed
Hinchcliffe: 155 minutes (1 carry per 7.04 minutes) 22 Hit-ups for 145m (6.5m per carry) 88 tackles 5 Missed
Here's Luke Bailey's stats after 4 games for comparison:
Bailey: 257 minutes (1 carry per 3.8 minutes) 67 Hit-ups for 590 metres (8.8m per carry) 128 tackles 5 Missed
Not great reading. Lowrie needs to go.
Blair: 188 minutes (1 carry per 5.52 minutes) 34 Hit-ups for 234m (6.8m per carry) 64 tackles 6 Missed
Norrie: 128 minutes (1 carry per 4 minutes) 32 Hit-ups for 249m (7.7m per carry) 67 tackles 1 Missed
Lowe: 81 minutes (1 carry per 3.6 minutes) 22 Hit-ups for 173m (7.8m per carry) 54 tackles 5 Missed
Manu: 181 minutes (1 carry per 6.03 minutes) 30 Hit-ups for 243m (8.1m per carry) 57 tackles 4 Missed
Proctor: 184 minutes (1 carry per 7.07 minutes) 26 Hit-ups for 199m (7.6m per carry) 71 tackles 3 Missed
Lowrie: 150 minutes (1 carry per 7.1 minutes) 21 Hit-ups for 130m (6.1m per carry) 65 tackles 6 Missed
Thompsom: 79 minutes (1 carry per 4.1 minutes) 19 Hit-ups for 137m (7.2m per carry) 48 tackles 3 Missed
Bromwich: 104 minutes (1 carry per 3.25 minutes) 32 Hit-ups for 247m (7.7m per carry) 63 tackles 7 Missed
Hinchcliffe: 155 minutes (1 carry per 7.04 minutes) 22 Hit-ups for 145m (6.5m per carry) 88 tackles 5 Missed
Here's Luke Bailey's stats after 4 games for comparison:
Bailey: 257 minutes (1 carry per 3.8 minutes) 67 Hit-ups for 590 metres (8.8m per carry) 128 tackles 5 Missed
Not great reading. Lowrie needs to go.
I agree Lowrie needs to go, not a big fan.
But Bailey is a different type of front rower to the ones we have. He has played origin, he is captain of his side, he is an old fashioned workhorse and he is the one of a couple of good players the Titains have.
But Bailey is a different type of front rower to the ones we have. He has played origin, he is captain of his side, he is an old fashioned workhorse and he is the one of a couple of good players the Titains have.
we had a bailey type player.... he then signed with the bulldogs. i think johnson and kite will be very good for us in the coming years if we keep them.
lowrie is still in because he knows how the team operates, but vea must be closing in on him after every match
lowrie is still in because he knows how the team operates, but vea must be closing in on him after every match
Tolman was such a big loss. DJ is playing great at NQ too.
Even Jeff Lima was a hard worker, not many Islander props come under that category. He was very disciplined too just like Tolman who rarely made mistakes.
Bromwiche will obviously become a top prop given a bit of time. Proctor is slowly getting there.
Lowe has been the biggest dissapointment for me, I just think he's not good enough to be in the team. Troy Thompson at least is reliable in defense.
[ Post made via BlackBerry ]
Even Jeff Lima was a hard worker, not many Islander props come under that category. He was very disciplined too just like Tolman who rarely made mistakes.
Bromwiche will obviously become a top prop given a bit of time. Proctor is slowly getting there.
Lowe has been the biggest dissapointment for me, I just think he's not good enough to be in the team. Troy Thompson at least is reliable in defense.
[ Post made via BlackBerry ]
- steaming stormer
- Tropical Cyclone
- Posts: 4045
- Joined: Tue Dec 02, 2003 5:34 pm
- Location: Altona Meadows
I have had a theory on Bromwich that if he holds the ball in his first hit up, he will fire.
Tonight he did that - i've been a fan of him since watching him in the under 20s - good to see him deliver in first grade tonight!
Tonight he did that - i've been a fan of him since watching him in the under 20s - good to see him deliver in first grade tonight!
every 'big' forward pack storm come up against the forwards dominate, first was manly and now the doggies, then the backs can have the space they need. i underestimated the pack in the pre season, and so did the rest of the comp by the looks of it
- Melbourne & Bears
- Squall
- Posts: 143
- Joined: Fri Feb 25, 2011 4:20 pm
From the original post, Todd Lowrie doesn't size up to his teams badly. Good amount of tackles, good amount of runs per metres and good amount of metres per run.
Perhaps copping some unwarranted negative comments by some fans.
[ Post made via iPhone ]
Perhaps copping some unwarranted negative comments by some fans.
[ Post made via iPhone ]
i give him a hard time on here because to me he doesnt look hungry on the field, i think a week or 2 in NSW/QLD cup might turn that around and make him go harder than what he has beenMelbourne & Bears wrote:From the original post, Todd Lowrie doesn't size up to his teams badly. Good amount of tackles, good amount of runs per metres and good amount of metres per run.
Perhaps copping some unwarranted negative comments by some fans.
[ Post made via iPhone ]
- Melbourne & Bears
- Squall
- Posts: 143
- Joined: Fri Feb 25, 2011 4:20 pm
Oh I agree, I'm one who has been critical of Lowrie. But his numbers aren't as bad as I thought.
[ Post made via iPhone ]
[ Post made via iPhone ]
-
- Weather Forecaster
- Posts: 46
- Joined: Mon Mar 31, 2008 12:13 pm
Just think how far our pack has come in the last 5 years. I cringe at the thought of the days when Kirk Reynoldson was running around.