Scott Dureau 5/8 replacement?

[Freshy]

Cant Chisholm play 5/8 aswell?

Not very well

I wouldnt be that blunt lol. He's got a good running game but a mediocre kicking game.

[BigG]

Cant Chisholm play 5/8 aswell?

Not very well

I wouldnt be that blunt lol. He's got a good running game but a mediocre kicking game.

I think he would be a fantastic winger.

[bula]

Although I've hardly seen Chisolm play, I'm really disappointed at his progress. (Only through our forumers opinions)

The fact that he's a winger now is a let down aswell.
Do you guys think he'll become a first grade player?

[Freshy]

Although I've hardly seen Chisolm play, I'm really disappointed at his progress. (Only through our forumers opinions)

The fact that he's a winger now is a let down aswell.
Do you guys think he'll become a first grade player?

Chisholm was always a winger to begin with, they moved him into five eigth because they wanted him to get his hands on the ball more. He's developed a very crafty running game because of it. He's progress hasnt been that bad really, you have to keep in mind he's a year younger then Duffie, O'Neill, Kelly and Widdop. He will definately be a first grade player.

[Michael :P]

Unless he pulls his finger out over the off season I doubt it will be here.

[The Eagle]

Scott Dureau? Are you Kidding?
NRL Nuffie imo,maybe Bellamy could mold him tho
He has done some good stuff,zero consistancy

[J-Storm]

In the immortal words of Phil Gould, "No no no no no!" Dureau &/or Herbert should be allowed nowhere near this side. We must have something in Kelly, Whiddop or someone else surely who already know the system? Not every reject from every other NRL club is going to work out & I'm rather adamant that those two named would be among that group...

[bula]

Am I the only one who likes Kelly?
I saw some good things from him, he's kicking was ok, he pulled off a 40/20.
Maybe we need a ball playing lock, we've never had one under Bellamy.

[Himitsu Arashi]

Like Luke but don't think Craig has come to a decision yet on what to do with him.
Let's call him a 'developing work in progress'
Along with Gareth there is a great career to be built at Storm,but think both they & we will need patience & trust.

[The Eagle]

Am I the only one who likes Kelly?
I saw some good things from him, he's kicking was ok, he pulled off a 40/20.
Maybe we need a ball playing lock, we've never had one under Bellamy.

Get Anasta

[TC]

Get Anasta

Get f***ed. 


Sorry, just kidding. But seriously, Anasta is even more over-rated than Scott Hill was. Don't need him, don't want him.

[steaming stormer]

If Anasta could be half as good as Hill I'd take him in a heartbeat

[The Eagle]

Get Anasta

Get f***ed. 


Sorry, just kidding. But seriously, Anasta is even more over-rated than Scott Hill was. Don't need him, don't want him.

ROFL so was i,very tongue in cheek comment

[The Eagle]

Actually,i have a better idea than Anasta

Chris Bailey,oh my god your so welcome to him
he would look smashing in purple,or yellow
or blue,green,black,blue,gray or even your next
jersey type,pink with purple polka dots

You can thank me when you see him play,he is
a utility player,you can even stuff the man in a
6 jersey,just never put him in 3 or 4

13 wouldnt be so bad,i'll tell you this guy trys
so hard,would be such an asset to melbourne

[Michael :P]

Am I the only one who likes Kelly?
I saw some good things from him, he's kicking was ok, he pulled off a 40/20.
Maybe we need a ball playing lock, we've never had one under Bellamy.

I like the skills he has but the only way he gets a starting role is if Cooper moves to 5/8. Which wouldnt be a bad idea but I cant see it happening.