Round 2 - Storm vs Warriors @ AAMI Park
https://www.melbournestorm.com.au/news/ ... arly-plea/
Melbourne Storm and Jahrome Hughes have reluctantly accepted the early plea and grading for his contrary conduct charge from Saturday night.
Whilst both Jahrome and the club fully support and totally endorse the protection of referees in our game, we believe Saturday’s incident was an accident.
Further, we believe the contact was unavoidable and the grading on the incident was too harsh given the circumstances where Jahrome was concentrating on making an important tackle in the context of the game and not fixated on the movements of the referee.
Jahrome has reached out to referee, Chris Butler, to apologise and reinforce that his actions were unintentional.
We are disappointed that an unsuccessful challenge on the grading would have also resulted in an extra week suspension.
We acknowledge the system is in place to avoid judiciary hearings but, in this case, we believe the risk of the penalty for contesting the charge is too high considering the circumstances of the incident.
In the end, the threat of an extra week suspension on top of our club’s bye next weekend was the overriding factor in our decision but we don’t believe this is a fair outcome.
Melbourne Storm and Jahrome Hughes have reluctantly accepted the early plea and grading for his contrary conduct charge from Saturday night.
Whilst both Jahrome and the club fully support and totally endorse the protection of referees in our game, we believe Saturday’s incident was an accident.
Further, we believe the contact was unavoidable and the grading on the incident was too harsh given the circumstances where Jahrome was concentrating on making an important tackle in the context of the game and not fixated on the movements of the referee.
Jahrome has reached out to referee, Chris Butler, to apologise and reinforce that his actions were unintentional.
We are disappointed that an unsuccessful challenge on the grading would have also resulted in an extra week suspension.
We acknowledge the system is in place to avoid judiciary hearings but, in this case, we believe the risk of the penalty for contesting the charge is too high considering the circumstances of the incident.
In the end, the threat of an extra week suspension on top of our club’s bye next weekend was the overriding factor in our decision but we don’t believe this is a fair outcome.
We must all hang together or, most assuredly, we shall all hang separately
- Papenhuyzen23
- Thunderstorm
- Posts: 769
- Joined: Sat Apr 15, 2023 12:40 am
Pretty soft from the club if I’m being honest, they believed it was unavoidable and had a good case and the public and media backlash has been huge, he would have got off for sure, even had Luai’s incident as precedence.
Strange one from the powers that be, but we move, next man up, Munster might have to play now
Strange one from the powers that be, but we move, next man up, Munster might have to play now
Nah, he was never going to get off.Papenhuyzen23 wrote: ↑Mon Mar 18, 2024 7:30 pm Pretty soft from the club if I’m being honest, they believed it was unavoidable and had a good case and the public and media backlash has been huge, he would have got off for sure, even had Luai’s incident as precedence.
Strange one from the powers that be, but we move, next man up, Munster might have to play now
Annesley took the line today in the weekly review that it is never acceptable to touch a ref. It was all done and dusted before it even goes to a hearing.
We must all hang together or, most assuredly, we shall all hang separately
-
- Hail Storm
- Posts: 347
- Joined: Thu Aug 12, 2021 8:08 am
It's pretty pathetic that the nrl isn't prepared to admit the ref played as much a part of that situation as jahrome did. They both made a mistake, but only one is getting any official punishment.TC wrote: ↑Mon Mar 18, 2024 9:03 pmNah, he was never going to get off.Papenhuyzen23 wrote: ↑Mon Mar 18, 2024 7:30 pm Pretty soft from the club if I’m being honest, they believed it was unavoidable and had a good case and the public and media backlash has been huge, he would have got off for sure, even had Luai’s incident as precedence.
Strange one from the powers that be, but we move, next man up, Munster might have to play now
Annesley took the line today in the weekly review that it is never acceptable to touch a ref. It was all done and dusted before it even goes to a hearing.
Criticising the ref is crazy. Maybe he should have known the surroundings a little better but he looks in a normal position to me.
I think Jahrome totally screwed himself by the obvious push/shove. Can’t claim it was an accident after doing that.
I think Jahrome totally screwed himself by the obvious push/shove. Can’t claim it was an accident after doing that.
-
- Hail Storm
- Posts: 347
- Joined: Thu Aug 12, 2021 8:08 am
Not really that crazy, it was poor situational awareness and positioning on the ref's part. They have a duty to not impact play, the same as the players have a duty to pass backwards, not be offside etc. Being able to remain close to the action without impacting play a skill that is vital to refereeing
It was a no win situation for jahrome. He could have played for the obstruction, but no guarantee it would have been awarded. He could have tried to go around the ref, only to arrive to late. When you've got normally anti Melbourne commentators saying jahromes a bit hard done by, that says plenty.
Agreed.Lennart Bedrager wrote: ↑Tue Mar 19, 2024 6:51 amNot really that crazy, it was poor situational awareness and positioning on the ref's part. They have a duty to not impact play, the same as the players have a duty to pass backwards, not be offside etc. Being able to remain close to the action without impacting play a skill that is vital to refereeing
It was a no win situation for jahrome. He could have played for the obstruction, but no guarantee it would have been awarded. He could have tried to go around the ref, only to arrive to late. When you've got normally anti Melbourne commentators saying jahromes a bit hard done by, that says plenty.
And in any case, it was in no wise worth 2 weeks.
Also it leaves a vile taste in the mouth when you consider that Luai deliberately shoved a ref out of the way last season to get to a try celebration and only got fined.
I guess after slapping Luai (see a trend here?) on the wrist for a high shot and a trip this week and totally ignoring Latrell's unapologetic foul mouthed press conference, Annesley felt the need to show that the NRL is tough on offenders.
We must all hang together or, most assuredly, we shall all hang separately