Judiciary: Isa to miss a week

[Super Cronk]

...i dont think  you will happy with anyone...unless they bring marcus  bai or kingy back to play winger. 

pretty much, lol
but nah, id love to see the coaches to a punt on a younger player who we havent seen the best of yet, its time we unearth more stars like GI, billy and izzy.

Not everyone is a freak like that....and the coaching staff do seem to find these gems ...maybe Isa is one of them but is battling with confidence or something....give him a few more shots i reckon...if Tomane was there on Friday...would it have been much of a difference? probably not IMO .

[Play the ball]

Ive spoken about dropping player....but with a new guy like this you dont drop him after 1 poor game...he will be shattered. But with that being said i thought Tomane was always going to get that starting spot...so i would like to see him there aswell.

Yeah I agree that is it right for Bellamy to give Isa a few more chances despite my strong belief that he's not the right player for the position

I wondered the same, there was a play , maybe half way through the second half, when he passed to Turner, just a standard passing situation it was,

He looked so awkard passing the ball to his right .... not ideal for a right centre,

But he looks like he has some natural power(for his age) and a good set of wheels, maybe he is better suited to the wing.

[nacho]

...i dont think  you will happy with anyone...unless they bring marcus  bai or kingy back to play winger. 

pretty much, lol
but nah, id love to see the coaches to a punt on a younger player who we havent seen the best of yet, its time we unearth more stars like GI, billy and izzy.

Not everyone is a freak like that....and the coaching staff do seem to find these gems ...maybe Isa is one of them but is battling with confidence or something....give him a few more shots i reckon...if Tomane was there on Friday...would it have been much of a difference? probably not IMO .

ill give him one more chance, if he blows it, hes out of my dreamteam!

[Super Cronk]

NOOOOOOOOOO...he will be crushed if you do that!

[nacho]

NOOOOOOOOOO...he will be crushed if you do that!

consistantly scoring under 20 points wont cut it in my team

[Super Cronk]

fair call.

is it the same for the forwards? they have to make 500 metres + or they get the boot?

[nacho]

fair call.

is it the same for the forwards? they have to make 500 metres + or they get the boot?

nah , at least 25 tackles, 1 point a tackle guarentees good points 

[Michael :P]

For those that are still looking for it 8:58minute mark in the first half. The actual grapple doesnt look to bad but he did grab the head on his second go.

[SeeYaSlater!]

has he been suspended yet?

[storm_rhinos]

Yes he just failed to beat the charge, so is out for a week

[Bourbon Rat]

Expected result  They couldn't possibly let a Storm player get off a 'grapple' charge. It would set a disturbing precident for others 

[TC]

If that deserves a week, Hodges deserved 3.

No, actually Hodges deserves a kick in the head - but he should have been suspended for at least 3 weeks.

[Surandy]

For those that are still looking for it 8:58minute mark in the first half. The actual grapple doesnt look to bad but he did grab the head on his second go.

Thanks for that Noa. NRL On Fox showed a replay of the tackle and on the vision shown I could see nothing in it. On replay though, the Hodges grapple looked way worse than I first thought and definitely deserved to be more than a grade one charge.

[Super Cronk]

Hodges could have broken cams neck with that twist. i couldnt even see contact with the players head when isa made his tackle.

[Michael :P]

For those that can be bothered go to the 75:55 mark in the Knights - Sharks game on Bigpond and tell me how that didnt get cited.